2006-07: Donohoe had an outstading indoor season running distance races for the Saints. His season was highlighted by two second place finishes in the 3000 meter run and the 5000 meter run at the NYSCTC Championships. His time of 14.53.82 in the 5000 meters was a season's best. Donohoe also led the way for the Saints at the ECAC Championships, placing third in the 5000 meter run with a time of 14:56.34. He took second at the Cornell "Deneault Invitational" in the 3000 meter run.

2005-06: Erik established the Liberty League record in the mile with a win in 4:25.83 and also earned All Liberty League honors in the 800, finishing second.
2004-05: Erik had an outstanding rookie season in cross country cut short by injury and could be a key contributor for the Saints in the middle and long distances once fully recovered. He came back strong in the track and field season, winning the 1500 in the Liberty League outdoor championships and leading off the champion 4x800 relay team. He was third in both the 1500 and 800 indoors.

At Masconomet Regional

Erik was a standout in both cross country and indoor and outdoor track and was one of the top distance runners in his conference.